If at First You Don't Succeed

By -
My drive to and from school each day has taken on quite a change over the past few months. It used to be that I would set my XM radio (The Loft and The Spectrum are my stations of choice) for a commercial-free and concentration-free commute. Lately, though I have been listening to the Steve Hargadon interviews from FutureofEducation.com and Conversations.net multiple times and each time I seem to find something new to spark ideas and get me thinking about education and things I should try in the classroom. One of those ideas is to create some online content for my students to watch and review from my own lessons, similar to what I have been doing with those recordings.

I planned to set aside some time this summer to create these lessons. These would be topics that I will cover and discuss in class, but can be viewed in a less interactive but maybe more visual format as often as needed. My thought was that this type of lesson would lend itself very well to a discipline like math, where an example could be worked through and then put online for students to examine as many times as necessary. It just seems to make so much sense to create examples of some of the more important (I know, I know, they are ALL important :)) or at least the ones that are more difficult to understand.

I mentioned this to a colleague who teaches math and she seemed somewhat opposed to the idea saying that the students would not pay attention in class if they knew it was going to be online. I have heard similar concerns about placing notes online for a class.

Are these legitimate concerns? What are the arguments for this practice in order to convince those who have their doubts about its effectiveness? While I have every intention of continuing with my intended project, it would be nice to help others do something similar in their discipline that would be effective for them.

Comments

  1. Paul BogushApril 14, 2010 at 1:30 PM

    If your lesson could be completed online then so be it-let the kids complete it and stay home ;)

    I think any great lesson cannot be taught online. If you are only offering in class what can be read online then I think something is missing from the lesson.

    Yes, factual info can be transmitted online, but those deep conceptual connections and individualized questions and group conversations which push the kids to make those conceptual connections and connect them to other contexts can only take place in class.

    So to the teacher who said students wouldn't pay attention in her class, I would say then maybe her class isn't worth paying attention to if some words on the internet can replace the face-to-face time that her students spend with her.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mr. Tom KrawczewiczApril 14, 2010 at 1:42 PM

    Paul,
    I totally agree with you about the connections that can only be made in the classroom and through a discussion. I have been part of discussions and classes online that are very close to the classroom setting, though. My point for the math teacher was to give students an opportunity for multiple viewings of an example that the teacher leads the class through. Have you ever thought you had a grasp of something only to realize you didn't totally understand later? This may give them an opportunity to look at it again and reconnect if needed. After all, we can reread material as often as we would like. So why not do the same for examples?

    Thanks for the comments and insight. They are greatly appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Heather DurninApril 30, 2010 at 6:29 AM

    Tom,
    I think your idea is well worth pursuing. This year, I have started to post some of my Notebook lessons on my class wiki. Not only can the students go back and review the lesson, but so too can their parents.
    The discussions moving through education increasingly focus on the teacher being the model/guide as students move into more higher-level thinking and drive their learning. Your suggestion blends well with this concept.
    I would be interested to see/know what tools you use to present your lessons as I too would like to spend more time this summer moving in that direction.
    @hdurnin

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Boost Learning in Presentations and Games

By -
For those teachers who use games for learning and review, it's apparent the rise in engagement that they bring to the classroom. But, does this engagement and enthusiasm always lead to learning? According to research by neuroscientist Paul Howard-Jones, adding an element of chance can help further increase the chances of learning. It's just a matter of adding it at the right time. For instance, the addition of a simple 50/50 chance of losing all points associated with a correct answer leads to more effective learning. But where in the process does the learning peak? I asked Howard-Jones via email and it turns out that the following sequence works well: student/team answers question student/team is given a 50/50 chance to "double or nothing" their points correct answer is revealed It turns out that even if they lose points or answer incorrectly, the learning is still at a peak because of the state of mind of ALL the students involved. Good or bad, even those who a
Read more

How do students know what they know? (an effective exit slip)

By -
I remember sitting in class a few (plus!) years ago and at times totally following what was going on. It could have been almost any subject but there were times when it seemed to click.  At least I thought so. Then I got home and started the homework. Different story. It just wasn't that clear anymore and I realized that I didn't quite get it the way I thought. This was not exclusive to homework as it also happened at times on quizzes and tests. I thought I had studied enough (which, admittedly was what I always thought) but it did not pan out. I want my students to avoid this problem and the trick is for them to answer the question: "How do I know when I really know it?" But how? I recently saw a tweet for a webinar run by Ray Jimenez, who is a great webinar presenter by the way, entitled "Learners Don't Know What They Don't Know." Of course, I was excited to get the long-awaited answer to my question in one interesting hour but, ironically e
Read more

How to Lead the Horse to Water?

By -
Apparently, I can't even lead a horse to water, much less make it drink. I held a tech session recently at school to introduce interested colleagues to free and ongoing professional development opportunities. The plan: show them several ways to learn online (Future of Education interview series (www.futureofeducation.com) and Learn Central webinars) and then show and have them sign up for Twitter and have it culminate in participation in a Tuesday edchat session. It was going to be great to show them immediately how to learn from others all over the world. One person showed. The week before I held a session on organization and document sharing. Two showed for that. I should have quit while I was ahead. Of course, it was in the middle of summer and I only gave them a few days notice so that could have been a big factor. Maybe the topics were not that exciting, interesting or maybe I used terms that had no appeal on their own. But I had a theory that I thought would make this
Read more